Hryhorii Perepelytsia
Doctor of Political Science, Full Professor, Director of the Foreign Policy Research Institute, Full Professor, Department of International Relations and Foreign Policy, Institute of International Relations, Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv
ORCID: 0000-0003-4000-1334
DOI: 10.37837/2707-7683-2021-40
Abstract. The author of the article examines the phenomenon of the Russian-Ukrainian conflict in Donbas, the main trends in its development and resolution, the strategies of the parties in this process as well as miscalculations and achievements of Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s diplomacy in gaining peace in Donbas and ending the war with Russia.
The author underscores that the Russian-Ukrainian war in Donbas is not only the most acute all-Ukrainian problem but also a sore international issue, which calls into question the existence and survival of the Ukrainian state, the future of European security and the current world order. Seven years into the war, which is officially referred to as the ‘Russian-Ukrainian conflict’, no answer has been found on how to end it. The issues of ending the war against Russia, reimbursing the losses caused by it, establishing peace in Donbas, and returning the occupied territories of Ukraine are the most significant in the foreign policy of President of Ukraine V. Zelenskyy. Yet, the diplomatic strategy he chose has not so far provided the definitive answer to this question, whose solution is expected by Ukrainian citizens both in the liberated and Russian-occupied territories of Donbas. The international community, including its security organisations, does not have a clear and unambiguous answer to this question as well.
This article is a certain attempt to analyse the efforts of V. Zelenskyy’s diplomacy to resolve this security problem over the last two years of his presidency. According to the author, the search for alternative ways to achieve peace has not brought the desired results this year. Therefore, Ukraine has only one choice – to recognise the Russian-Ukrainian war as a reality and to be ready for Russia’s large-scale military aggression at any moment.
Keywords: Russian-Ukrainian conflict, diplomacy, Normandy format, Minsk process, ‘Yermak plan’, election, strategies of the parties, war, peace, ‘Steinmeier formula’.
References
1. ‘8 stsenariiv konfliktu na Donbasi: ryzyky, mozhlyvosti ta nebezpeky’ (2020). Yevropeiska pravda, 25 March [online]. Available at: https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/articles/2020/03/25/7107962/ [in Ukrainian].
2. Butusov, Yu. (2019). ‘Zustrich roku v Paryzhi. Shcho bude dali?’. NV, 10 December [online]. Available at: https://nv.ua/ukr/opinion/zelenskiy-putin-peregovori-pozitiv-i-negativ-pislya-zustrichi-normandskoji-chetvirki-v-parizhi-novini-ukrajini-50058410.html [in Ukrainian].
3. Honchar, M. (ed). (2016). Gibressiya Putina. Nevoennyye aspekty voyn novogo pokoleniya. Fragmenty issledovaniya v ramkakh proekta “Antares” [Putin’s Hybression. Non-Military Aspects of New Generation Warfare. Fragments of the Study in the Framework of the Antares Project]. Kyiv: Tsentr globalistiki ‘Strategiya XXI’. [in Russian].
4. ‘Hromadska dumka pro sytuatsiiu na Donbasi ta shliakhy visnovlennia suverenitetu Ukrainy nad okupovanymy terytoriiamy (sotsiolohiia)’ (2019). Razumkov Centre, 11 October [online]. Available at: https://razumkov.org.ua/napriamky/sotsiologichni-doslidzhennia/gromadska-dumka-pro-sytuatsiiu-na-donbasi-ta-shliakhy-vidnovlennia-suverenitetu-ukrainy-nad-okupovanymy-terytoriiamy [in Ukrainian].
5. ‘Yevroparlament u rezoliutsii proponuie vidkliuchyty Rosiiu vid systemy SWIFT u vypadku ahresii proty Ukrainy’ (2021). Radio Svoboda, 29 April [online]. Available at: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/news-rosija-evroparlament/31230189.html [in Ukrainian].
6. ‘Zakon pro kolaboratsionizm vzhe v Radi: za shcho mozhut daty dovichne’ (2021). UNN, 25 February [online]. Available at: https://www.unn.com.ua/uk/news/1917999-zakon-pro-kolaboratsionizm-vzhe-v-radi-za-scho-mozhut-dati-dovichno [in Ukrainian].
7. ‘“Zapad daet Rossii signaly”: kogda vstretitsya “Normandskaya chetverka” i zavershit li ona voynu na Donbasse’ (2019). Inpress.ua, 6 September [online]. Available at: https://inpress.ua/ru/politics/52383-zapad-daet-rossii-signaly-kogda-vstretitsya-normandskaya-chetverka-i-zavershit-li-ona-voynu-na-donbasse [in Russian].
8. ‘Zelenskyy vpevnenyi, shcho za svoiu kadentsiiu zakinchyt viinu na Donbasi’ (2020). Ukrainska pravda, 22 April [online]. Available at: https://www.pravda.com.ua/news/2020/04/22/7248937/ [in Ukrainian].
9. ‘Zelenskyy: Na Donbasi postriliuiut. Na zhal, hynut’ (2020). NV, 8 March [online]. Available at: https://nv.ua/ukr/ukraine/politics/zelenskiy-pro-situaciyu-na-donbasi-na-donbasi-postrilyuyut-na-zhal-ginut-novini-ukrajini-50074499.html [in Ukrainian].
10. Zolkina, M. (2021). ‘Vse pro novyi plan Yermaka: shcho proponuiut u “Normandii” dlia onovlennia Minskykh uhod’, Yevropeiska pravda, 25 March [online]. Available at: https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/articles/2021/03/25/7121333/ [in Ukrainian].
11. Embassy of Russian Federation in France (2021). ‘K voprosam uregulirovaniya vnutriukrainskogo konflifta’, 20 July [online]. Available at: https://france.mid.ru/ru/presse/interview_pi_kozak_ru/ [in Russian].
12. ‘Konflikt na Donbasi peretvoryvsia z mizhnarodnoho na vnutrishnii: analiz brytanskykh ZMI’ (2020). 24 kanal, 17 March [online]. Available at: https://24tv.ua/konflikt_na_donbasi_peretvorivsya_z_mizhnarodnogo_na_vnutrishniy_analiz_britanskih_zmi_n1299181 [in Ukrainian].
13. ‘Kravchuk nazvav dva mozhlyvi kompromisy dlia Donbasu’ (2020). Ukrainska pravda, 31 July [online]. Available at: https://www.pravda.com.ua/news/2020/07/31/7261366/ [in Ukrainian].
14. ‘Kravchuk nazval uslovie dlya vyborov na Donbasse v marte’ (2020). Khvylia, 13 November [online]. Available at: https://hvylya.net/news/219277-kravchuk-nazval-uslovie-dlya-vyborov-na-donbasse-v-marte [in Russian].
15. ‘Kravcuk rozpoviv pro “Plan spilnykh krokiv” na Donbasi’ (2020). Radio Svoboda, 5 November [online]. Available at: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/news-kravchuk-donbas-plan-spilnyh-krokiv/30931541.html [in Ukrainian].
16. ‘Kreml obnarodoval otvet Putina na vopros o vozmozhnosti vklyucheniya Donbassa v sostav RF’ (2021). Novosti Donbassa, 14 February [online]. Available at: https://novosti.dn.ua/news/308684-kreml-obnarodoval-otvet-putyna-na-vopros-o-vozmozhnosty-vklyuchenyya-donbassa-v-sostav-rf [in Russian].
17. Martynets, S. (2019). ‘Pristayko rasskazal o planakh po zaversheniyu voyny na Donbasse’, Segodnya, 3 September [online]. Available at: https://politics.segodnya.ua/politics/pristayko-rasskazal-o-planah-po-zaversheniyu-voyny-na-donbasse-1325236.html [in Russian].
18. ‘Minskiye dogovorennosti: denonsirovat nevozmozhno, vypolnit tozhe’ (2021). Krym. Realii, 19 June [online]. Available at: https://ru.krymr.com/a/zelenskiy-danilov-eksperty-minskiye-soglasheniya/31316003.html [in Russian].
19. ‘Novaya voennaya doktrina RF: podgotovka k masshtabnoy voyne’ (2019). Ukrainskaya pravda, 9 March [online]. Available at: https://www.pravda.com.ua/rus/news/2019/03/9/7208764/ [in Russian].
20. Pahulych, R. (2020). ‘Za rik zakinchyty viinu ne vdalosia – shcho robytyme Ukraina dlia myru na Donbasi dali?’, Radio Svoboda, 6 December [online]. Available at: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/rik-zelenskoho-bez-myru/30984028.html [in Ukrainian].
21. ‘Peredvyborcha prohrama kandydata na post Prezydenta Ukrainy Volodymyra Zelenskoho’ (2019). [online]. Available at: https://program.ze2019.com/ [in Ukrainian].
22. ‘Peremyria vzhe nemaie. Kravchuk vyslovyvsia shchodo ataky rosiian na Donbasi’ (2021). ASPI News, 10 February [online]. Available at: https://aspi.com.ua/news/politika/peremirya-vzhe-nemae-kravchuk-vislovivsya-schodo-ataki-rosiyan-na-donbasi#gsc.tab=0 [in Ukrainian].
23. President of Russia (2014). Poslanie Prezidenta Federalnomu Sobraniyu [Presidential Address to the Federal Assembly], 4 December [online]. Available at: http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/47173 [in Russian].
24. ‘Prohres vidsutnii: Zelenskyy rozpoviv Merkel pro sytuatsiiu na Donbasi’ (2021). Priamyi, 15 January [online]. Available at: https://prm.ua/prohres-vidsutniy-zelenskyy-rozpoviv-merkel-pro-sytuatsiiu-na-donbasi/ [in Ukrainian].
25. ‘Piat stsenariiv rozvytku podii u Donbasi: choho ochikuvaty vid Rosii, i yak mozhe vchynyty Ukraina?’ (2020). Dzerkalo tyzhnia, 15 March [online]. Available at: https://zn.ua/ukr/internal/p-yat-scenariyiv-rozvitku-podiy-u-donbasi-chogo-ochikuvati-vid-rosiyi-i-yak-mozhe-vchiniti-ukrayina-341575_.html [in Ukrainian].
26. Riabinin, Ye. (2013). Kontseptsiia kerovanoho khaousu v konteksti pobudovy suchasnoho svitovoho poriadku [The Concept of Controlled Chaos in the Context of Modern World Order Making]. Zovnishni spravy, no. 11, pp. 32–37. [in Ukrainian].
27. Sydorenko, S., Zolkina, M. (2020). ‘Dialoh na umovakh Kremlia: shcho stoit za “myrnym planom” Yermaka dlia Donbasu’, Yevropeiska pravda, 14 March [online]. Available at: https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/articles/2020/03/14/7107510/ [in Ukrainian].
28. Sydorenko, S. (2019). ‘Persha normandska: yak ta u chomu Zelenskyy peremih Putina na samiti v Paryzhi’, Yevropeiska pravda, 10 December [online]. Available at: https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/articles/2019/12/10/7104052/ [in Ukrainian].
29. Stryzhova, O. (2020). ‘Zaboroneni miny, zbilshennia kilkosti obstriliv ta DRH na Svitlodarskii duzi: lystopad na Donbasi’, Radio Svoboda, 4 December [online]. Available at: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/30984355.html [in Ukrainian].
30. ‘Stina – tse ne prosto slova, – Zelenskyy pro “plan B” shchodo Donbasu’ (2021). 24 kanal, 25 June [online]. Available at: https://24tv.ua/stina-tse-ne-prosto-slova-zelenskiy-pro-plan-b-shhodo-donbasu_n1667074 [in Ukrainian].
31. ‘Ukraina proponuie v plani dlia TKH prypynyty konflikt i demilitaryzuvaty ORDLO na pochatku 2021 r., shchob 31 bereznia 2021 r. provesty tam mistsevi vybory’ (2020). Interfax Ukraine, 5 November [online]. Available at: https://ua.interfax.com.ua/news/political/701179.html [in Ukrainian].
32. ‘Ukraina proponuie plan po Donbasu: Prypynyty konflikt i demilitaryzuvaty ORDLO na pochatku 2021 roku, a v berezni provesty tam vybory’ (2020). Rubryka, 5 November [online]. Available at: https://rubryka.com/2020/11/05/ukrayina-proponuye-plan-po-donbasu-prypynyty-konflikt-i-demilitaryzuvaty-ordlo-na-pochatku-2021-roku-a-v-berezni-provesty-tam-vybory/ [in Ukrainian].
33. ‘U MVS zaiavyly, shcho hotovi vidnovyty control nad Donbasom, ale potribne rishennia Zelenskoho ta Verkhovnoi Rady’ (2021). Rubryka, 7 March [online]. Available at: https://rubryka.com/2021/03/07/u-mvs-zayavyly-shho-gotovi-vidnovyty-kontrol-nad-donbasom-ale-potribne-rishennya-zelenskogo-ta-verhovnoyi-rady/ [in Ukrainian].
34. ‘Fokin zaiavyv, shcho vystupaie za osoblyvyi status dlia vsoho Donbasu’ (2020). Mind, 30 August [online]. Available at: https://mind.ua/news/20215118-fokin-zayaviv-shcho-vistupae-za-osoblivij-status-dlya-vsogo-donbasu [in Ukrainian].
35. Tsaruk, N. (2019). ‘Tsina myru – kapituliatsiia pered Rosiieiu: ekspert poiasnyv, chym nebezpechni “hibrydni” telekanaly Putina’, ZNAJ.UA, 28 June [online]. Available at: https://znaj.ua/politics/242907-cina-miru-kapitulyaciya-pered-rosiyeyu-ekspert-poyasniv-chim-nebezpechni-gibridni-telekanali-putina [in Ukrainian].
36. ‘Eks-sovetnik Putina nazval glavnoe zadanie Zelenskogo pri vstreche s Baydenom’ (2021). Khvylia, 1 August [online]. Available at: https://hvylya.net/news/234878-eks-sovetnik-putina-nazval-glavnoe-zadanie-zelenskogo-pri-vstreche-s-baydenom [in Russian].
37. Yasko, Ye. (2020). ‘Chotyry zahrozy “novoho Minska”: chomu v “Sluzi narodu” ye sprotyv domovlenostiam pro ORDLO’, Yevropeiska pravda, 23 March [online]. Available at: https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/articles/2020/03/23/7107795/ [in Ukrainian].
38. Brooks, L. (1984). Escalation and Naval Strategy. United States Naval Institute Proceedings, vol.110, no. 8. [in English].
39. Dulebova, I. et al. (2018). War and peace: ways to peace in war in the Eastern Ukraine. Skhid, no. 5(157), pp. 59–65. [online]. Available at: https://doi.org/10.21847/1728-9343.2018.5(157).148638 [in English]. 10.21847/1728-9343.2018.5(157).148638